Does Not Having Children Make You Selfish?

Written by Christine Kane

stepmother.jpg[This is part 2. Click here to read part 1.]

Ah, yes.

The selfishness hook.

It works wonders, doesn’t it?

Especially on women.

I’ve coached hundreds of women, both at my retreats and in my on-line seminar.  The fear of being “selfish” comes up often when a woman is making a choice that goes against the traditional cultural model, or if her desire is different from what everyone expects.

Nowhere is this more true than in the “to have kids or not” question.  This is a major trigger point.

Women have heard this one very strange outmoded story for too long: that women who choose a life without their own children are clearly selfish because they are choosing their own “freedom” or “ambition” over the delight of raising and serving other human beings.

I call it The Selfishness Myth.

And I have exactly six things to say about it:

1 – Not having children makes you not have children.  That’s all.

2 – Having children is not the Automatic Selfishness Release Lever.

A simple stroll around the aisles of any Super Wal-Mart will show you that.

3 – People who label others as selfish are most often not “creators.”  They are “getters.” 

(See my post Creating vs. Getting for more about this.)

Let’s face it.  Most people are not clear. Most people live life from a place of reaction, not Creativity.  Most people try to get things in life, and don’t know how to create things in life.

When these people meet someone who makes clear choices, or sets boundaries, or treats herself with care, or only says yes if it’s an Absolute Yes – then it looks like selfishness.

That’s because when you live in the Getting place, then your very survival necessitates a world where other people are unclear and don’t make healthy choices and aren’t sure what they want.

That’s because “getting” involves strategies and manipulation. Manipulation requires that other people don’t have any boundaries or clarity about their time, money, and choices.

So, the word “selfish” is convenient.  It allows the labeler not to have to look at her own feelings of powerlessness. Instead she just feeds her ego and puffs-up her world-view.

4 – There is no point in getting vitriolic about people who play the “selfish” card.

They are not mean or bad or evil. They are merely unconscious.  And they’ve never taken the bold steps to discover their own huge power to create their lives.  They are scared.

5 – Redefining Selfishness is necessary.

When you step begin to “Live Creative,” and you get clear about what you want and how to create it from the inside out, then you’ll often have to stop waiting for others to validate your choices. Instead you will have to Redefine Selfishness.

6 – If you want to Redefine Selfishness, try this definition on for size:

It is not selfish to choose to live how you want to live. It is selfish to expect other people to live how you want to live.

Given that definition, we all know many parents who – no matter how many offspring they produce – will never become unselfish.

And when it comes to parenting, the simple act of asking whether or not you want children might be a wise and bold and unselfish first move.

Add to del.icio.us Stumble It! Subscribe to this feed Digg it


{ 2 trackbacks }

The 9 Skills Every Woman Should Master
March 30, 2010 at 12:03 am
Perilously Precocious » Blog Archive » Your Fearless Leader-Woman
April 13, 2010 at 7:35 pm

{ 52 comments… read them below or add one }

Diana April 24, 2011 at 12:22 am

wow… I am so overwhelmed with this decision of having or not having kids! I’m deliberately looking for other people who have made choices not to have them and see how their lives have turned out at the end. It’s silly but wish there were chronicles like that!;) although it looks like the conscious decision of not procreating by healthy women – is a relatively new trend. In-spite of the obvious benefits of living the “SELFISH” fulfilled, creative, happy lives, full of free time where we can travel the world, do exciting things and occasionally help others or even nurse abandoned children whenever we have that urge to serve – always on our own free willing terms… we still struggle with the NEED to know whether IT’S OK not to have kids of our own even if we don’t really feel the strong maternity instincts.
This is hard because our nature designed us to “herd”, just like animals, we do what most of us are doing and any deviation from following the majority gives us an anxiety. Same goes for us judging others who act too differently from us. We can’t help it. We need to know that big decisions in our lives will be socially accepted. I understand it and I don’t like it… and yet I’m looking for others to give me an advise (which most likely will have absolutely no impact on my decision anyways, because advises I will get will be something like – “Do what you want”:))
So… I guess the real decision here is to find strength to separate myself from the crowd and TO NOT CARE whether someone tells me “I’m selfish” or “what’s wrong with you?”. Then perhaps I will see more clearly if I want to have that kid who would have my eyes:)

[Reply]

J. S. October 27, 2011 at 11:05 am

Great article. Selfishness is a separate entity from parenthood.

Being selfish in regards to being childfree is particularly asinine, because being selfish is only a bad thing when it negatively impacts others; if there are no children, whom is being hurt?

The childfree have more time, money and energy to help their families, friends and others who need help. Parents are often too bogged down with their immediate responsibilities to do much beyond their own home. The childfree have the ability to contribute in a multitude of ways.

If the logic that having children makes you unselfish were true, selfishness would have been long eradicated in this world full of 7 billion people. I’m ready for this “argument” to die out already.

[Reply]

Leave a Comment

You can use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>